Grill Comparison Reports

Weber 10020 vs 40020 Smokey Joe Comparison

Weber 10020 vs 40020

Both come with a cooking grate whose diameter is measured to be 14.5 inches. As advertised, these portable Weber grills are triple nickel-plated, and are ideal for cookouts, tailgate parties, and car camping.

But which one of these will you take for any of the said events? To help you with the answer, here’s our Weber 10020 vs 40020 comparison report.

Comparison Chart: Weber 10020 vs 40020

Here’s a chart that serves as a quick reference and guide. Scroll down and you’ll quickly spot the differences between these two portable charcoal grills from Weber.

Weber Grill
Model Check Price » Weber 10020 Check Price » Weber 40020
Other Name Smokey Joe Smokey Joe Premium
Fuel Charcoal Charcoal
Dimensions (Lid Closed) 17″H X 14.2″W X 14.5″D 17″H X 14.2″W X 16.5″D
Diameter (cms) 14 14
Cooking Area (sq. in.) 147 147
Glass-Reinforced Nylon Handle 1 1
Rust-Resistant Aluminum Dampers 2 3
Plated Steel Cooking Grate
Heavy-Gauge Steel Charcoal Grate
Porcelain-Enamelled Bowl and Lid
Aluminum Ash Catcher
Tuck-n-Carry Lid Lock

Key Differences

As you’ve seen in the chart above, these Weber charcoal grills share more similarities than they have differences. However, one area that they differ in can be a dealbreaker.

Below is a list of these grills’ main differences.

Ash Pan

The Weber 10020 come with an ash catcher directly underneath the grill, which makes cleaning very easy and very convenient. Unfortunately, the Weber 40020 doesn’t come with an ash pan.

Lid Lock

The Weber 40020 has a lid lock while the Weber 10020 doesn’t come with one.


The Weber 40020 has 3 dampers. In comparison, the Weber 10020 comes with 2 dampers.

Use the images below to further compare these two Weber portable grills.

Our Final Word: Weber 10020 vs 40020

Which of these two do we recommend? Get the Weber 10020. It’s a tried-and-tested portable grill with consistent positive feedback from consumers. More importantly, the presence of an ash pan at the bottom is a huge plus.

Also Read: Hamilton Beach 25360 vs 25361: What’s the Difference?